Found a great resource? Share it!
Yes. The guide says a review of the literature is required in every EE, “regardless of pathway and subject(s) selected” (p. 38). It’s how you show the knowledge and understanding that Criterion B rewards. It counts as part of the body of your essay.
What changes from subject to subject is where it goes and how it looks:
Biology, Chemistry, Physics, SEHS, ESS: usually its own section after the introduction, covering the theory behind your question and what earlier studies found.
Mathematics: a short section on the area of maths and the known results you build on. The guide says it’s mandatory here too (p. 69).
History: the interpretations you’ll weigh, set out early and then used throughout your argument.
Economics, Business Management, Geography, Global Politics: the theory and key studies, often in a short section of their own, then applied throughout.
Psychology: the whole essay is a review of the literature, an analysis of peer-reviewed research (p. 56).
Language A and Language B: published criticism woven into your argument. Language A must include “a review of the existing literature” (p. 44).
Interdisciplinary: literature from both subjects, plus any work that already connects them.
Not sure where yours should go? Ask your supervisor. Where it goes is a judgement call; having one is not.
A literature review should tell a story; it isn’t a list. You synthesise and analyse, and it has a beginning, a middle and an end. Synthesis finds the links between ideas and points out where they differ.
To synthesise, you relate one idea to another and use them to form something new. The scientist in me likens this to making a new compound from two elements: you all know what happens when sodium meets chlorine. A good literature review does the same. It appraises your sources, pulls out their key ideas and makes sense of them under one overarching idea.
Beginning: outline the idea and the debate your question sits in.
Middle: analyse and synthesise, theme by theme.
End: summarise the differences, puzzles and open questions, and show where your investigation fits.
Listing: One study found that lichen diversity was lower near roads. Another found that nitrogen-tolerant species were more common near roads.
Synthesis: Studies near roads agree that lichen communities change, but not on why. Some measure nitrogen dioxide, others dust and bark pH, so it is still unclear which matters most. My fieldwork measures both.
See the difference? The second version groups the studies, says where they agree and disagree, and ends by pointing at the gap your essay fills.
Here is a template you can print to hand write on.
This is how I do it. It’s advice, not a rule, so borrow whatever helps.
Skim and spot themes. I find papers I want to read and skim them, jotting down themes as they come up, both the ones I’m looking for and the ones that just appear.
Read properly. I read them in full, usually printed or on my iPad, with a different coloured highlighter for each theme so I can track it across papers.
Use the Matrix Method. One row per source, one column per theme. There’s a version for you below; I normally do mine by hand (because I’m old!).
Find the flow. I look at how the ideas connect, work out a good order and map it out.
Give each theme a page. I give each theme its own page in my essay document and gather everything relevant there. Then I write my own text at the top and strike through what I’ve used.
Or go analogue. Sometimes I cut the papers up into a pile for each theme and write straight from the piles, scribbling out what I’ve used.
It works in two stages: plan first, then write.
Whatever you do, summarise and critique theme by theme, never author by author.
Blank Template
Writing author by author instead of theme by theme.
Summarising sources without judging them. Say how strong each one is and why.
Including only sources that agree with you. The disagreements are often the most useful part.
Drifting away from your research question. If a source doesn’t help answer it, cut it.
Using it to fill space; every source should earn its place.
Academic Phrasebank: Referring to sources (University of Manchester), for phrases that introduce and weigh other people’s work.
Academic Phrasebank: Comparing and contrasting, for the language of synthesis.