Found a great resource? Share it!
Critical writing is where you stop reporting what you found and start thinking with it. You take evidence, ideas and other people’s views and use them to build a reasoned argument that answers your research question.
It matters because Criteria C and D, analysis and line of argument, and discussion and evaluation, are worth 14 of your 30 marks. An essay that mostly describes or summarises can’t score well on either. The guide puts it bluntly: a largely descriptive or narrative essay is unlikely to show enough analysis (p. 40).
In Short
Description tells the reader what happened or what a source says. Critical writing explains how and why, and what that means for your research question.
Critical writing:
makes claims and backs them with evidence
weighs ideas, sources and methods
compares different viewpoints
spots limitations and gaps
explains why evidence matters
links back to the research question
shows judgement, not only knowledge
Critical writing is not:
retelling the story
describing what you read
listing facts
giving opinions without support
repeating what scholars say
adding information without analysing it
Strong essays use the same handful of moves again and again. Here they are, with the criterion each one feeds. The criteria names come from the guide; matching moves to criteria is my advice.
Analyse. Break evidence, data or an argument into parts and show how they work. Criterion C: analysis.
Compare. Show how two ideas, methods, results or interpretations relate. Criteria C and D.
Evaluate. Judge how reliable, valuable or significant something is, including your own sources and methods. Criterion D: evaluation.
Interpret. Explain what a finding means and why it matters. Criterion D: discussion.
Synthesise. Bring sources together to make a point none of them makes alone. Criterion C: line of argument.
Justify. Explain why you chose a method, text, case, theory or data source. Criterion A: research methods.
Link back. Connect each point to your research question. Criterion C: line of argument.
Students often ask what critical writing sounds like. These help you get going; change them so they sound like you.
Analysis
The evidence suggests that…
A closer look shows…
This indicates that…
Comparison
In contrast to…
Similarly, the findings of…
Both sources suggest that…
Evaluation
This source is convincing because…
A limitation of this study is…
The argument is weakened by…
Interpretation
This implies that…
One possible reading is…
This may point to a wider issue with…
Synthesis
Taken together, these findings show that…
Combining these views makes it clear that…
Justification
This method was chosen because…
This source suits the research question because…
Link back
This helps answer the research question because…
This supports the argument that…
Point, Evidence, Technique, Analysis, Link. Make your point, give the evidence, name the technique, explain what it shows, then link it to your research question.
Technique fits literature and the arts best. In other subjects, read T as the method, data or theory behind your evidence. Use PETAL to plan, then loosen it so your essay doesn’t read like a template.
Descriptive
“The protest was large and took place in the city centre.”
Critical
“The size of the protest suggests strong public anger, but its central location made it unusually visible, so turnout alone may overstate support.”
Descriptive
“The experiment showed an increase in reaction rate.”
Critical
“The increase in reaction rate supports the hypothesis, but the spread across trials suggests temperature control may have affected the results.”
Descriptive
“Author A argues that nationalism is rising.”
Critical
“Author A claims nationalism is rising, but relies on polling from one region, so it is unclear how far the trend applies elsewhere.”
Critical writing looks a little different in each subject. This is my advice; check your subject page for the details.
Sciences (Biology, Chemistry, Physics, SEHS, ESS): discuss uncertainties and anomalies, say whether your data really support the hypothesis, compare with published values or studies, and be honest about the limits of your method.
Mathematics: justify each step, explain why your method suits the problem, and discuss the assumptions and limits of any model.
History: weigh sources by origin, purpose, value and limitation, and compare historians’ interpretations instead of reporting them one by one.
Economics and Business Management: apply theory to your real-world data, then question the theory’s assumptions and how reliable the data are.
Geography and Global Politics: weigh different perspectives, stakeholders and scales, and ask whose view each source represents.
Psychology: evaluate the studies themselves: sample, method, ethics and how far the findings generalise.
Language A: analyse how the writer’s choices create meaning and effect, using short quotations, and argue with the critics as well as citing them.
Language B: analyse how language and culture shape the text or issue. Work from sources in the target language; translated texts aren’t acceptable.
The Arts: use the subject’s own vocabulary for form and technique, and tie close analysis to context.
Interdisciplinary: show what each subject’s lens adds and where they pull in different directions. The critical work happens in the connection.
Use your literature review to set up the debate. Critical writing grows out of disagreement between sources.
Treat evidence as something to test, not accept. Ask whether it’s strong or weak, complete or partial.
Signpost your argument. The guide describes a line of argument as logical connections with signposts, so the reader can see where it came from and where it leads (p. 40). Topic sentences and short links between sections do this.
Make every paragraph move the argument forward. If a paragraph could be cut without the argument changing, it’s description.
Keep your sources’ words to a minimum. The guide warns against over-extensive quoting; your knowledge needs to show in your own writing (p. 40).
Keep coming back to the research question. Leave out anything that doesn’t help answer it.
Evaluation isn’t a paragraph at the end. The guide asks you to weigh the strengths and limitations of your research materials, and to be aware of the stated or implied positions of the writers (p. 41). For each important source, ask:
Who wrote it, when, and for whom?
What evidence does it use, and how much?
What might the author want you to think?
What can’t it tell you?
How does it compare with your other sources?
Then say what your answers mean for your argument. That last step is what turns a checklist into evaluation.
Template to print and write on.